When Search Starts Keeping the Traffic

Search is shifting from a gateway to the web into a system designed to keep users inside it. Google’s AI search features, including AI Mode and AI Overviews, surface answers directly while linking users back to Google-owned properties rather than external sites. In some cases, a significant share of citations, around 17 percent, now loop users into another Google search, with YouTube emerging as another heavily cited destination. The result is a more contained browsing experience where users move across Google products instead of exploring the broader web.

For publishers, this represents a structural change in how traffic flows. Many websites have historically relied on search as a primary distribution channel, but AI-generated summaries reduce the need to click through. Even when links are present, they may lead to another layer of Google results rather than the source. This creates a disconnect between content creation and audience capture, where publishers contribute information but receive less direct engagement in return.

The experience is also changing for users. While AI summaries promise faster answers and easier navigation through follow-up queries, they can create circular journeys that do not always resolve the original question. Instead of comparing multiple sources, users may stay within a single system that prioritizes continuity over exploration. Over time, this can narrow the range of perspectives people actively encounter.

At a platform level, the incentives are clear. Keeping users within the ecosystem increases search activity and strengthens monetization through ads and engagement. But it also accelerates a broader shift toward a zero-click internet, where discovery happens without meaningful traffic flowing outward. As this model evolves, the balance between platforms, publishers, and users is being renegotiated, and the long-term impact on the open web remains uncertain.

Q1 is almost over. Q2 is your window.

Let Spacebar Studios build out your newsletter, completely free. They handle everything from ICP refinement to template design and sample drafts. After month one, you're ready to hit the ground running.

The Farmer’s Dog is a U.S.-based direct-to-consumer pet food company that delivers fresh, personalized meals for dogs. In a category dominated by retail distribution and performance marketing, the company took a different route by building its growth engine around owned channels, with email playing a central role in how it acquires and converts customers.

Instead of pushing users directly toward purchase, The Farmer’s Dog focused on capturing email early in the journey and using it to educate potential customers. Prospects entering the funnel receive content that explains pet nutrition, ingredient quality, and feeding benefits, helping them understand the product before committing. This approach shifts the focus from immediate conversion to building trust over time.

The email program is deeply integrated with personalization. Content is tailored based on each customer’s dog profile, including breed, size, and dietary needs. Messages include feeding recommendations, product education, and reminders that feel relevant.

Email also plays a critical role in retention. After purchase, customers continue to receive content that reinforces product value, supports usage, and maintains engagement. The company uses ongoing education and personalization to reduce churn and increase lifetime value.

This has increased their email-to-conversion rate by 8% and achieved a purchase CPA that was 23% under goal. Over time, this strategy has allowed The Farmer’s Dog to scale efficiently in a competitive DTC market. By treating email as both a conversion and retention system, the company built a durable growth engine rooted in trust, personalization, and owned distribution.

AI-generated search summaries are starting to influence how users perceive brands before they ever visit a website. A recent analysis found that Google’s AI Overviews show more negative brand mentions compared to traditional search results, often pulling in reviews, complaints, or critical context alongside basic information. When compared with ChatGPT, it is still 44% more likely to be negative about brands. Even dated negative news stories and past customer feedback can influence AI responses. This shifts control away from brand-owned messaging and toward aggregated, model-generated narratives.

As AI mediates discovery, brand perception is being shaped earlier in the journey. Companies that manage how they are represented across the broader information ecosystem, not just their own websites, will have a meaningful advantage.

Traffic is becoming less dependable, so growth has to come from what you control. Brands that win are the ones that turn first-time visitors into repeat audiences and then into customers over time. The Farmer’s Dog shows how this works in practice. Capture attention once, then use email to educate, build trust, and drive repeat purchases without relying on constant acquisition. Stop optimizing only for getting seen, and start building systems that keep people coming back.

See you next week.

If you liked this edition of Growth Curve, forward it to a founder who needs to stop renting audience — and start owning it.